Breaking in a Glove

How to Break in a Baseball Mitt: Step-by-Step Tips & Best Products to Use

Breaking in a new baseball glove is a rite of passage for players at every level. A fresh mitt right off the shelf is often stiff and hard to manage—but with a little effort, patience, and the right tools, you can mold it into the perfect fit for your hand and playing style.

Here’s a comprehensive guide to breaking in a baseball mitt the right way, along with some of the best products to help you get the job done.

Why Break in Your Glove?

A brand-new glove is like a blank canvas. Breaking it in softens the leather, forms a pocket, and helps the glove flex and close properly. It’s not just about comfort—it’s about performance. A well-broken-in glove improves your grip, control, and confidence on the field.

Step-by-Step Guide to Breaking in a Baseball Mitt

1. Apply Glove Conditioner or Oil

Start by applying a light layer of glove conditioner or oil to the palm, pocket, and webbing. This softens the leather and helps it start to form.

✅ Best Products:

• Rawlings Glovolium Glove Oil

• Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner

• Pecard Leather Dressing

Pro Tip: Avoid using too much oil—it can oversaturate the leather and shorten the glove’s lifespan.

2. Shape the Glove

Once the leather is conditioned, begin shaping the glove. Focus on forming the pocket where you want the ball to sit. Fold the glove and wrap it around a baseball (or two, for a deeper pocket).

✅ Recommended Tools:

• Glove Mallet: Use it to pound the pocket and hinge areas to simulate ball impact.

• Ball & Bands: Put a baseball in the pocket and secure the glove with rubber bands or a belt to hold its shape overnight.

3. Play Catch—A Lot

There’s no substitute for real use. The best way to mold your glove to your hand is by simply playing catch. Every ball caught helps naturally break in the leather.

Bonus Tip: Try to play catch every day for 10–15 minutes over a couple of weeks.

4. Store it Properly

Always store your glove with a ball in the pocket to maintain its shape. Keep it in a cool, dry place and never leave it in your car or direct sunlight, as heat can dry out and damage the leather.

Optional: Use a Steaming or Heat Method (With Caution)

Some sporting goods stores offer glove steaming services, which speed up the break-in process. You can also carefully use a hair dryer to warm the leather (not too hot), but this method should be used sparingly to avoid damage.

Avoid These Common Mistakes

• Over-oiling your glove.

• Baking or microwaving the glove (yes, people try this—don’t do it).

• Using shaving cream with lanolin, which used to be popular but can harm modern glove leathers.

Final Thoughts

Breaking in a baseball mitt takes time, but the payoff is worth it. A glove that fits like a second skin helps you play with confidence and precision. Whether you're a Little Leaguer or a seasoned player, take care of your mitt—and it’ll take care of you on the field.