Choosing the Best Youth Mitt

A Comparison Guide for Parents and Players

When your child steps onto the baseball field, one of the most important pieces of equipment they’ll need is a well-fitting, high-quality mitt. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to figure out which glove is the right choice. This guide will break down key features, compare popular youth mitts, and help you choose the best fit for your young player’s needs.

What Makes a Great Youth Mitt?

Before diving into specific brands, it’s important to understand what makes a good youth mitt. Here are the key factors:

• Size: Youth gloves typically range from 9” to 12”. The ideal size depends on the player’s age and position.

• Material: Leather gloves are more durable and offer a better break-in, but synthetic options are lighter and easier for young hands.

• Web Style: Closed webs are ideal for pitchers, while open webs suit infielders who need quicker ball transfers.

• Fit & Comfort: Adjustable wrist straps and a snug fit are crucial for younger players.

Top Youth Mitts Compared

Let’s look at some of the best-rated youth baseball mitts available and how they stack up.

1. Rawlings Players Series Youth Glove

• Best for: Beginners, ages 5–9

• Material: Synthetic leather

• Sizes: 9”–11.5”

• Pros: Lightweight, affordable, game-ready

• Cons: Limited durability compared to full leather

• Price Range: $20–$35

Verdict: A great starter glove that’s easy to use right out of the box.

2. Wilson A500 Youth Baseball Glove

• Best for: Intermediate players

• Material: Full-grain leather

• Sizes: 10”–11.5”

• Pros: Durable, high-quality leather, excellent feel

• Cons: Slightly more expensive, requires break-in

• Price Range: $60–$80

Verdict: Ideal for serious youth players ready for the next step up in performance and feel.

3. Mizuno Prospect PowerClose Series

• Best for: Young players needing help with catching

• Material: Leather/Synthetic blend

• Sizes: 9”–12”

• Pros: PowerClose technology helps kids close the glove, soft lining for comfort

• Cons: Break-in still required, synthetic parts less durable

• Price Range: $40–$60

Verdict: A smart option for younger kids who need a little help securing the ball.

4. Easton Future Elite Youth Glove

• Best for: Competitive players age 9–12

• Material: Genuine leather

• Sizes: 11”–12”

• Pros: Built for performance, fits smaller hands well

• Cons: Higher price point

• Price Range: $70–$90

Verdict: A high-quality mitt for kids playing at a more competitive level.

Final Thoughts: Which Mitt Should You Choose?

• For Beginners (T-Ball or ages 5–8): Rawlings Players Series or Mizuno PowerClose

• For Advancing Players (Ages 8–12): Wilson A500 or Easton Future Elite

• For Comfort and Ease of Use: Mizuno’s PowerClose is hard to beat for kids still learning to catch confidently.

No matter what mitt you choose, make sure your child has time to break it in before game day—and most importantly, that it feels good on their hand. A glove that fits well will help boost their confidence and performance on the field.

Pro Tip: Don’t forget to use glove conditioner and a baseball to help break in a new mitt quickly and naturally.